مثال 1
Text 1
Readers often treat Mary Shelley's 1818 novel Frankenstein as a warning against scientific ambition. In this reading, Victor Frankenstein's downfall is a punishment for overstepping the natural limits of human knowledge.
Text 2
What destroys Victor is not that he creates life but that he abandons what he has created. The creature turns violent only after being rejected by Victor and by everyone else he meets. Shelley's novel is less a warning about science than a warning about failing to take responsibility for one's creations.
Based on the texts, how would the author of Text 2 most likely respond to the reading described in Text 1?
Readers often treat Mary Shelley's 1818 novel Frankenstein as a warning against scientific ambition. In this reading, Victor Frankenstein's downfall is a punishment for overstepping the natural limits of human knowledge.
Text 2
What destroys Victor is not that he creates life but that he abandons what he has created. The creature turns violent only after being rejected by Victor and by everyone else he meets. Shelley's novel is less a warning about science than a warning about failing to take responsibility for one's creations.
Based on the texts, how would the author of Text 2 most likely respond to the reading described in Text 1?
- أIt overlooks that Victor's central failure in the novel is his refusal to care for the being he made.
- بIt correctly identifies scientific ambition as the novel's main concern.
- جIt wrongly assumes that the creature is violent from the moment it is created.
- دIt ignores the scientific training that Shelley received as a young woman.
اعرض الحل
الإجابة الصحيحة: أ
يرى كاتب النص الثاني أن خطأ فيكتور الحقيقي هو هجر مخلوقه لا الطموح العلمي، فالقراءة الأولى تغفل هذا. أما خيار عنف المخلوق منذ خلقه فلا يرد في النص الأول أصلا.
